Yesterday I happened to see this entry from Silk Road International Blog.(“Foreigners Not Welcome”) I thought I would write something about it – not for my own purpose, but for many foreign people living in China, especially those I know of or those I know are very passionate about China and Chinese people. And some of them even adopt one, two or three Chinese orphans and love them as much as any parents could do their biological children.
For quite long time, I have been a foreigner living in a few western countries and I have been befriended by many friends, colleagues of different races and nationalities. To many of them, I owe appreciations for their help and friendship; I behold their friendship very so much that it is not possible for me to keep silent when I saw the blog entry, for I keep wondering what these friends of mine would think if things like that happened to them?
I am not going to defend or denounce any positions in this blog nor giving my reading on China's politics. I am trying to avoid saying any political opinions as much as possible -- not because that I have none or am afraid of any repercussions of any sort. It is not the purpose of this piece for one, and secondly I bite my political tongue out of respect for any political views of my friends or other readers of this blog may hold about China. All of us may have different views and this blog is not the place for political speech. I simply just want to share some of my thoughts derived from my experiences of a Chinese living in a foreign country and some cultural cues that I believe would be easily understood and shared by any foreigners living in a country other than their native one.
I have no doubt that many Chinese these days may not feel like foreigners in their country for various reasons. The mention in that blog of "a group of relatively well dressed office people" in Shenzhen, the most developed city in China, is even more disturbing. They are supposed to be the beneficiary of China's economic growth and open policy towards the outside world. I also agree with the author's view that the fanatic patriotism is not entirely orchestrated by the government or the media, although they have a role to play. Although an authoritarian government is able to tone down patriotic frenzy, China does become more liberal and it is hard to stop people developing any ideas including xenophobia. Unfortunately, growing sense of freedom and technologies can help advance xenophobic ideas as well. See how IM or SMS worked to advocate boycott of the French retailer Carrefour. It is the most vivid display of how modern technologies available to people can work for their cause in this day and age.
When I was first in France many years ago, I was quick to learn "Le Front National" led by Jean-Marie Le Pen, the political party and its leader of notorious anti-foreigners movement in France. I was scared to learn what they were about at the time when my French and knowledge of France even couldn't allow me to move freely around Paris by myself. I was lucky enough that I was surrounded by many good French people and they were willing to help in any way they could. I lived there for several years while watching Le Pen's party almost won the primary election, the skinhead parade, and physical attacks or murders of North African immigrants as well as socialists' street demonstrations of anti-extreme right. All these happened in one country and in the eyes of a Chinese living in a foreign country.
So what did I think?
I was sometime scared to listen and to watch what had happened in France. I was probably lucky that I didn't encounter any of bad and scary incidents. Even if anything of that kind did happen to me, I refuse to link France or French people to any stereotype of Le Front National. Yes, there are people who do not like foreigners in that country for whatever reasons. That is a fact, and I had to live with it. But I also knew that there were far more friendly people and cooler heads in that country towards foreigners that would easily outnumbered the bad guys I might encounter during my stay. To this day, those events have not bothered me a tad bit to think that France is deeply rooted for liberty, equality and fraternity. And that has nothing to do with the followers of Le Pen's party.
I do not mean to single out France as a case in point. There are Neo-Nazi in Germany, Russia, and many other countries as well. Even in the US, the country to which I am still a legal Resident Alien (a racist, in my opinion, yet official term of permanent resident), there is this politician called Pat Buchanan saying that millions of oversea Chinese from Singapore to San Francisco hold secrete loyalty to the Chinese government. (See reference) Loyalty to China? I may say it is patriotism. To the Chinese government? I think some overseas Chinese may be insulted. In addition, he did not take his ideas to the street; instead, like Jean Marie Le Pen, he took microphone and broadcast his xenophobic ideas on TV networks or on paper. He brought them to the presidential campaign platform. People cannot stop him doing it in a democracy.
Do I expect Chinese people to do the same if true democracy or freedom is allowed in China, as many foreigners advocated? Yes. It is just normal and a statistical certainty that a tiny percentage of 1.3billion population will make a huge noise and tantalize the media, which in turn, arouses more people's frenzies. Westerners may find it too ironic that democracy or freedom that they advocated for Chinese so hard will be used against westerners themselves. If that does happen, we still have to bear with it and call it a democracy, don't we?
I do expect that there is more of xenophobic sentiment growing as China becomes more integrated into the world. This is simply an outcome of China getting more heterogeneous while being integrated into the world. Yesterday, right before reading the author's post, I happened to have a phone conversation with a person living in Shenzhen, the same city the blog author lives in. One thing that person mentioned to me, quite to my surprise, may be a bit telling: she said she hated to see this torch relay that disturbed many people's work schedule and in the end, most people saw nothing as there were just too many people on the streets.
Be careful with what we wish for and be prepared for what we wish for. What if the "Chinese Buchanan" airs his anti-foreigners message on TV networks – in the name of freedom of speech? As a foreigner, what would you think of living in China with that type of messages flying around?
I share the author's frustration and upset. I commend his action to ignore whoever spat racist language to him. I would do the same in the similar situation. I would also like people to know that I believe most of Chinese belittle that behavior. For every one Chinese that you see have anti-foreigner sentiment, there are far more numbers of Chinese who hold genuine hospitality towards foreign people. Or, at least, please count yours truly as one of the many. For the same reason, I believe the author's statement that for most part of his experiences in China, they are the pleasant ones…
Better, if foreigners bring their money or factory orders to any place west of longitude 110E in China, you would be treated like VIP hand over fist. My point is not that foreigners are welcome because they need investments or business orders, although I do think many Chinese' work and life depend on that. There is no denial that most Chinese have no reasons to resent foreigners for any particular reasons, despite the torch relay saga or the foreign media's reports. For the latter, I think the Chinese are coming to the realization that the foreign media is operating on a commercial basis with missions of catching sensational pictures or mind-jolting headlines to attract audience or readership. Even if Chinese are irritated by misleading information reported by the foreign media, their angers are not the source for any long-lasting anti-foreigner movements.
Whatever China is to become in the long term is probably beyond control of any people living there—both native and foreign. We have to accept—the things we like or we do not like. In the case of foreigners living in China, just ignore the latter. This may require a bit of mental preparation for a fast changing China, for better or for worse. For those who are used to the preferential treatment of foreigners, the changes can be quite dramatic. But by my experiences of a Chinese living in different foreign countries, I am pretty much sure that pleasant memories and friendship associated with a foreign country will always overwhelm any bad experiences I may have—if I open the heart and respect people I live with.
Today, I just saw for the first time in a mall the outfits of the 2008 Canadian Olympic Team. They are beautiful. And those three golden embroidered knitting of Chinese Characters of "加拿大" (Canada) along with the English name on the clothes are quite eye-catching in white-red background color. To print Chinese characters on the clothes may be a smart design if it is to win over some Chinese cheering for the Canadian teams during the competitions. Will it work? I am not sure. But I was quite certain that these outfits were "Made in China". So when I flipped a jersey and saw the tag, I did not get surprised.
No matter what this Olympic Game brings to China, there is no way to shut out China in the world stage. I hope cooler heads both inside and outside China will have a long and hard thinking about this country and wisdom will prevail. I also hope that the current situation would be like any episodes in the past such as boycotting Japanese goods three years ago in China, or, in the American case, the "Freedom Fries" episode in the eve of Iraq war. After all ordeals, China is preparing two lovely Pandas for Japan and Mr. Sarkozy was invited to G. W. Bush's ranch in Crawford, Texas. Politics and history never fail to remind us constantly how absurd we human being can be.
And most of all, I do hope my friends, in any way related to China, may find comforts from these words of a Chinese who, like many of you, lives in a foreign country. I believe that these thoughts do represent the thinking of a very large percentage of Chinese both inside and outside China. That's what this blog entry is all about.
Enjoy China if you live or work there, or do both. Enjoy the Games if you are a sport fan.